Building a DIY Compost Sifter

by | Apr 20, 2021 | Grow, Soil

Making your own compost is a great way to eliminate waste and save some money to create healthy soil full of rich microorganisms and beneficial components. Having a DIY compost sifter will help utilize your compost to create a homemade seed starting mix or potting soil, or to gently cover your seeds when planting them in the garden.

A man holding a compost sifter over a wheelbarrow.

For us, good gardening practices include preparing our garden for winter after all our crops have been harvested, avoiding the most common gardening mistakes, using no-till gardening methods, and doing our best to keep weeds out of the garden.

One of the best things you can do for your garden is to have great soil. Like I always say, “Dirt is dead!” We want our gardens filled with beneficial bugs, insects and other microorganisms to help our crops grow and provide for our family.

A large compost pile inside a barn.

Do you need to sift compost?

You may be wondering why you would need to sift compost or soil. There are two reasons you should sift compost:

  • For removing larger material
  • To create soil for a seed starting mix (or potting soil)

If you’d like to leave a comment on this video, head on over to YouTube!

When starting seeds or transplanting tiny seedlings, you need to have very fine soil to lightly cover the seeds.

If your soil has large chunks of debris, this could interfere with the germination of the seed and your germination rate will decrease, wasting both time and money.

In order to have the best success when planting, using a fine soil is necessary. Sifting your homemade compost or store-bought soil is key.

A large pile of compost with a barn in the background.

How do you sieve a large amount of soil?

Depending on the volume of soil, you may need to sift a large amount of soil. This DIY compost sifter works well for small or relatively large amounts. Even on our property here at Riverbend where we make 14-20 cubic yards of compost a year, this sifter meets our needs.

How or where you locate your sifter can be determined based on the volume of soil. For example, if you have larger amounts, you may wish to hang your sifter from above, allowing you to easily shake the sifter back and forth.

For smaller quantities, placing the sifter over a wheelbarrow, as I demonstrate in the video above, will work just fine.

A man holding up one side of a compost sifter.

Building a DIY Compost Sifter

Supplies Needed

  • 2×3 or 2×4 boards – cut to the dimensions of your desired sifter. 1x boards are not recommended as they’re not quite strong enough for larger loads.
  • 1/4 inch hardware cloth – this is rigid enough with small enough holes to get our soil down to the size we want. You could go 1/8th inch, but you’ll have to work harder and I’ve found 1/4 inch is fine enough.
  • 3″ screws – to secure the boards together at the corners.
  • 3/8″ T50 Staples – To secure the hardware cloth to the frame.
Drawn plans on graph paper for how to build a compost sifter.

Assembling the Compost Sifter

  1. Measure and cut your boards to size. A 2’ x3’ sifter works over a wheelbarrow really well. So if you are using 2x material, your side pieces would be 3’ long and your ends would be 2’9” long.
  2. Once you have your boards measured and cut, simply screw the pieces together at the corners, forming a rectangle (careful not to screw too close to the edges or you risk splitting your board). Use two screws per corner.
  3. Measure and cut the hardware cloth to size. I cut my cloth to line up to the very edges of my boards. Make sure you cut the hardware cloth square.
  4. ¼” hardware cloth is pretty rigid so you won’t need to stretch it out or anything, just lay it over your wood frame…if you cut everything right, the edge should all line up and you can then staple the hardware cloth to the frame. This is going to hold a bit of weight, so don’t be shy with the staples. I like to put them about every 3”…and make sure they are well set!
A man showing a compost sifter.

Compost Sifter Dimensions

I built our compost sifter specifically to fit on top of our wheelbarrow. Our frame is 3’x2’9″. The arms of the sifter rest directly on the wheelbarrow for support and it fits all around both length and width.

Hanging Compost Sifter

If you lack the strength to shake your compost sifter back and forth by hand, you may want to build your sifter with eye-hooks and rope or chain, then hang it from a ceiling or structure overhead.

This would allow you to fill the sifter with soil, then swing it back and forth without actually having to deal with the weight of the soil and sifter.

A man holding up sifted compost in his hands.

How to Use a Compost Sifter

Using your compost sifter is easy! Just dump a shovel full of compost or soil onto the metal screen, then sift the compost or soil through the screen with your hands or your shovel.

Alternatively, you can shake the screen back and forth allowing the compost or soil to fall through the screen.

Dump the larger pieces of compost back into your compost pile to continue to break down.

Two people using a BCS tractor to spread soil over a garden row.

Adding a fresh layer of sifted compost directly over our garden rows not only adds nutrients to our soil, but it also acts as a natural mulch to protect our seedlings and suppress weeds.

Creating your own compost and sifting your own soil is much more economical than buying $10 bags of seed starting mix in order to plant your garden. With this inexpensive DIY compost sifter, you’ll be well on your way to a beautiful garden.

Even our little kids know that sifting compost is important!

Home Composting (Troubleshooting & FAQs)

Home Composting (Troubleshooting & FAQs)

Learning how to start a compost pile (the easy way) and when and how to turn your compost pile are the first steps in home composting. But sometimes you run into issues or questions that aren't covered in a basic DIY or composting 101. We're here to answer all your...

read more

Great to meet you!

It is our goal to encourage you in the path to a more healthy, more secure and free lifestyle by sharing and teaching the skills that lead to greater sustainability and self-sufficiency for you, your loved ones and your community.

– Carolyn and Josh 


Eggs Eggs
Water Glassing Eggs
Eggs Eggs
Easy Canning Stew

Confidently Start Using Herbs for Your Family!

Learn my SYSTEMATIC approach to herbal healing.

– Carolyn

  • Use the “SAFE HERBS” for your family
  • Choose the RIGHT HERB

woman holding homemade herbal remedies




Healthy Healing at Home

Free 4 video workshop on how to confidently use homemade herbal remedies!


Learn my SYSTEMATIC approach to herbal healing at home.

- Carolyn